Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) has put a hold on President Joe Biden’s pick to lead the State Department’s Middle East bureau, according to an email obtained by POLITICO, escalating the Texas Republican’s battle with the administration over diplomatic nominations and opening a sensitive, new policy fight.
In the email, Cruz’s team explained to Senate Foreign Relations Committee GOP offices why the lawmaker was seeking to delay the panel’s approval of Barbara Leaf, a top Middle East National Security Council official nominated to be the assistant secretary of State for Near Eastern affairs.
According to the email, Leaf didn’t answer three of Cruz’s written questions to the senator’s satisfaction, and in one case Cruz’s team claims the NSC official lied.
Cruz asked Leaf to detail any “arrangements, deals, or agreements that are being contemplated by the Biden administration to reduce pressure on Iran” instead of a return to the 2015 nuclear deal. “There have been no such arrangements, deals, or agreements contemplated to reduce pressure on Iran,” Leaf responded.
“That testimony is false,” reads a two-pager Cruz’s team attached to the email. In the footnotes, Cruz’s team cited two Reuters stories reporting the U.S. considered taking small steps with Iran as a confidence-building scheme, and another about American officials pondering a “less for less” alternative, which would require fewer restrictions on Tehran’s nuclear work in exchange for fewer lifts on sanctions. Neither story says the goal of those other arrangements were expressly to “reduce pressure on Iran,” but rather reports on ongoing diplomatic discussions and considerations between Tehran and Washington.
The senator also asked to see internal State Department documents instructing staff to refer to Israel’s deals with Arab nations as “normalization agreements” and not the “Abraham Accords” — though the Biden administration still uses the Trump-era term. Leaf said she was “not in a position” to share such documents as a nominee, but said she would “respond to your concerns” once confirmed by the full Senate.
The State Department’s long-standing view is that it’s not within a nominee’s authority to hand over documents to a Congressional committee. Only the agency can do so.
Cruz also asked three questions about Egypt, but his main one was about the 16 individuals detained by Egypt in what the U.S. has flagged as a gross human rights violation. He wanted to know if the $130 million the U.S. is withholding from security aid to Cairo is contingent on their release, as well as the names, affiliation and specific charges against those individuals. Furthermore, he’d like to know if any of the 16 people are members of Islamist groups and whether the administration intends to grant them U.S. visas if they were to be released.
Leaf’s long answer to those queries didn’t please Cruz’s team — and neither did any of her answers overall. “Leaf wrote back responses running to almost a thousand words. She answered 0 of the questions,” notes the two-page document.
“We asked the State Dept. to have her take another run at the questions — the point was to get answers, not do gotchas. They didn’t respond for a couple weeks, and then after Leaf was cleared they sent us an email saying that if we wanted rewrites my boss should lift his Nord Stream 2-related holds,” read the email from Cruz’s staff to Senate allies.
As a result, Cruz will hold Leaf’s nomination, forcing the administration to either explain its Middle East policy more fully, put pressure on Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer to spend precious floor time blowing past the hold, or pull her nomination altogether.
Leaf didn’t respond to a request for comment.
Cruz’s move tightens his vise grip on Biden’s diplomatic nominations during a time when the Iran nuclear deal is falling apart, tensions with China are ramping up, refugees want out of Afghanistan and sensitive climate change negotiations are coming to a head.
At the same time, Cruz is signalling a willingness to allow other largely non-controversial State Department nominees to sail through without additional hurdles. The Foreign Relations Committee, of which Cruz is a member, is slated to advance dozens of nominations later Tuesday, including ambassadorships for former Sens. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.) and Tom Udall (D-N.M.), as well as Cindy McCain and Julianne Smith, Biden’s pick to represent the U.S. at NATO headquarters. Leaf’s nomination is the only one that will be delayed during Tuesday’s markup.
But it also opens a new front in Cruz’s policy fights with Biden. The Texas senator’s holds on nominees began as a protest against the administration’s decision to waive mandatory sanctions on the nearly completed Nord Stream 2 pipeline from Russia to Germany. Cruz and many critics believe that was a strategic blunder, as it will give Moscow more influence in Europe.
Now the Texan is taking on the administration’s handling of the Middle East. Cruz is a longtime critic of the Iran deal and would prefer the U.S. remain out of the pact, while he also remains a supporter of the Trump-negotiated Abraham Accords between Israel and Morocco, Sudan, Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates.
It’s expected that Cruz will now bring up his misgivings with Biden’s Middle East policy during Foreign Relations Committee meetings this week, escalating already high tensions between the lawmaker and the administration.